Carpets & Flooring

Carpet vs Timber Stairs – Which one is right for you?

March 9, 2022

Carpet vs Timber Stairs Which one is right for you

By Tony Chalhoub, founder of CarpetAce

Short answer: Choose carpet if grip, comfort and a quieter house matter most, which suits young families, older people and pets. Choose timber if you want a sharp, architectural look that’s easy to sweep, and you’re happy to manage noise and slipperiness with good nosings or a non-slip finish. Stair carpet installation is $600 for a staircase of up to 16 steps, plus the carpet and underlay (our stair carpet guide has worked prices), and if timber, hybrid or vinyl is going through your home, we can quote the stairs at the same measure.

Stairs take more wear than any other part of a home. After more than 20 years installing carpet, here’s how I’d weigh up the two.

Carpet vs timber stairs at a glance

Carpet Timber
Grip underfoot Good, even in socks Slippery without nosings or a non-slip finish
Noise Quiet; absorbs footsteps Loud; footsteps carry through the house
If someone falls A softer landing Hard edges
Cleaning Vacuum with a stair tool; blot spills Sweep and wipe
Wear Shows first on the nosings Scratches and wears through the finish
Look Warm and soft Clean and architectural

Carpeted stairs

Carpet is the practical choice for most family homes. It gives grip underfoot, makes a fall less painful, and absorbs the sound of footsteps, which you’ll notice most on stairs beside bedrooms. If your upstairs is carpeted, running the same carpet down the stairs gives a seamless look.

The trade-offs: carpet needs regular vacuuming with a stair tool, spills need blotting straight away, and the nosings wear first because every footstep lands there. What makes stair carpet last:

  • Go dense. A dense pile wears better and is less likely to open up and show the backing where it bends over each nosing.
  • Twist or tight loop. A twist pile or a tight level loop both suit stairs. Avoid loose loops if you have pets, because claws catch.
  • Check the rating. Make sure the carpet is rated for stairs.
  • Use a good underlay. It adds comfort and helps the carpet keep its looks.

At the measure we bend samples over a stair edge so you can see how each one looks before you choose. Carpet starts from $20.50/m² supply, including GST, and our carpet prices page has the full breakdown. Stair installation is $600 for up to 16 steps; see what stair carpet costs for worked prices.

Timber stairs

Timber looks sharp, especially on an open or feature staircase, and the right colour and finish can tie the stairs into the floors around them. It doesn’t hold dust or hair the way carpet does, so a quick sweep and a wipe keep it clean.

The downsides are noise and grip. Footsteps carry, and timber is slippery in socks, which matters with toddlers, older family members and dogs. Non-slip finishes and grooved or inset nosings help. Solid timber treads can be sanded and refinished later; hybrid and vinyl can’t be sanded, but our hybrid and vinyl ranges have matching stair nosings for a neat, finished edge.

If you’re putting timber, hybrid or vinyl flooring through your home, we can quote the stairs at the same measure. See our stair carpet and flooring page.

Which one is right for you?

Choose carpet if you have young children, older family members or pets, the stairs are next to bedrooms, or you want a warm, quiet home.

Choose timber if the staircase is a design feature, it’s in an open living area, or it’s mainly adults using it and you’re happy to manage the noise.

Or both: a carpet runner on timber stairs gives grip and quiet in the middle while the timber shows at the edges. We install carpet runners on timber stairs too; overlocking the runner’s edges is an extra charge.

Frequently asked questions

Is it safe not to have carpet on the stairs?

Timber stairs can be safe, but they’re more slippery, especially in socks. Non-slip nosings or finishes make a real difference. Carpet gives more grip and a softer landing if someone does fall.

Do the stairs and floors have to match?

No. Many homes have carpeted stairs between hard floors downstairs and carpet upstairs. Choose stairs that suit the floors they connect, in colour as well as material.

Are stair runners safer?

Generally, yes. A runner adds grip and softens footsteps on timber stairs, and it’s much safer than slippery bare treads. It must be fixed firmly, so it can’t move underfoot.

Do stairs need to be darker than the floor or lighter?

Neither. Stairs often look best a touch darker, which hides wear on the nosings, but any colour works if it fits the room. Make sure each step’s edge is easy to see.

Doing your stairs? See our stair carpet installation page. Every staircase is different, so stairs are measured and quoted on site.

Book a free measure and quote

We’ll bring samples to your home, measure every room and email a written quote within 24 hours of the measure. Book your free measure and quote or call 0425 552 816.

Free in-home consultation

See the samples in your own home

24-month workmanship warranty · Written quote within 24 hours of the measure · Installed in one to two weeks, normally · Samples at your home or our Huntingdale showroom